Nurse Night Shift Differential Pay by State: The Posted Numbers and the After-Tax Reality
What is nurse night shift differential pay by state? The posted numbers cluster in a narrow band, $4 to $7 an hour in most current listings, but the number that hits your bank account swings by state for a reason most job postings never mention: your state's income tax decides how much of the differential you actually keep.
The posted rates, from real listings
Here is what hospitals are actually posting right now. Penn State Health's Lancaster Medical Center lists an evening differential of $2.50 an hour and a night differential of $5.00 an hour. Their Pennsylvania Psychiatric Institute in Harrisburg posts $5 an hour for night shift. A Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania posting lists $5 an hour for nights, 7pm to 7am. Down in Nashville, a Universal Health Services behavioral health listing posts $4 an hour for nights, $3 an hour for weekend days, and $7 an hour for weekend nights.
Skilled nursing facilities, which are hiring hard under the 2026 CMS staffing rule, are posting $5 to $10 an hour for night shift RNs. The pattern is clear enough: $4 to $7 is the mainstream band for hospital RNs, and the high end shows up where staffing is desperate or where premiums stack. If you are comparing offers in two states, the posting gap between them is usually a dollar or two. The keep gap, after taxes, can be bigger. That is the part below. Run your own numbers with the shift differential calculator.
The state slice: what you keep
Take the same nurse everywhere: $40 base, three 12-hour shifts a week, a $5 differential on all 36 hours. That is $180 a week and $9,360 a year in differential pay. Federal and FICA take the same bite in every state. The state tax slice is what moves.
| State | Gross per year | Kept per year | Kept per shift | Keep rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Texas | $9,360 | $6,586 | $42 | 70% |
| Pennsylvania | $9,360 | $6,299 | $40 | 67% |
| Colorado | $9,360 | $6,174 | $40 | 66% |
| New York | $9,360 | $6,081 | $39 | 64% |
| California | $9,360 | $5,762 | $37 | 62% |
Single filer, 2026 federal brackets, no pre-tax deductions; Pennsylvania and New York figures exclude local income tax, which widens the gap further.
The honest rule of thumb: you keep roughly two-thirds of a night differential. $60 a shift becomes $37 to $42. In a lot of places that is a car payment; it is just not the sticker number. The tax question in detail is in Is Night Shift Differential Taxed More?, and the annual math in What a Night Differential Adds Per Year.
Two things to ask before you sign
First, ask whether the differential applies to the whole shift or only the night hours. A 7pm to 7am shift where the differential covers only hours after 11pm pays a very different number than one that covers all twelve. Second, ask whether differentials stack. The Nashville posting shows how stacking works: weekend nights at $7 beat weeknights at $4 by $3 an hour, or $36 a shift. Some facilities stack weekend and night premiums; some pay only the higher of the two. The offer letter tells you which.
And if the posting says "competitive differentials" without a number, ask for the number. High-need units and SNFs are posting $5 to $10 an hour openly, which means the market rate is not a secret. A facility that will not name its differential is telling you it is below market. More on the negotiation angle in How to Negotiate Shift Differential, and whether nights are worth it at all in Is the Night Shift Differential Worth It?.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the average night shift differential for nurses by state?
Posted night differentials in current listings cluster around $4 to $7 an hour: $5 an hour for RN night shifts at Penn State Health in Pennsylvania, $4 an hour for nights at a Nashville behavioral health hospital, and $5 an hour in a Wilkes-Barre posting. Exact rates vary by facility and market.
Which states keep the most of the night shift differential after taxes?
States with no income tax keep the most. On a $5 an hour differential over three 12-hour shifts a week, a Texas nurse keeps about $6,586 a year (70%), while a California nurse keeps about $5,762 (62%).
Is the night shift differential taxed at a higher rate?
No. Differential pay is taxed as ordinary income at your marginal rate, same as base pay. It feels like more because the extra income stacks on top of your base pay and is withheld at your highest marginal rate.
Do weekend nights pay more than weekday nights?
Usually. A Nashville hospital posting lists $4 an hour for weeknight shifts, $3 an hour for weekend days, and $7 an hour for weekend nights. Weekend and night premiums often stack.
Can I negotiate my shift differential?
Sometimes. Differentials are usually set by facility policy, but high-need units and SNFs scrambling under the 2026 CMS staffing rule have posted $5 to $10 an hour, which gives you leverage.
Calculate Your Differential Pay
Enter your base rate, differential, and schedule to see your gross and estimated take-home.
Calculate My Differential Pay